Ideas for Mitigation of the Effects of a Reduced Water Year


Mitigation

 

Managing a Potato Crop with Less Water

 

                      Deficit Irrigation; Managing a Potato Crop with Less Water                                             

                                             Dr. Jeff Stark, University of Idaho 

            Irrigation is required for profitable commercial potato production in the western U.S. Potatoes have a relatively shallow root zone and a lower tolerance for water stress than most other crops grown in Idaho.  The preference for producing this drought sensitive crop in coarse-textured soils with limited water holding capacity makes precise irrigation management a necessity to obtain optimum yield and quality. When restricted water availability reduces potato production potential, options for increasing water use efficiency need to be considered.

There is a direct correlation between reduction in irrigation and reduction in yield. Each reduction of one inch of irrigation reduced yield by about 24 cwt/a.    

 .94 R2 correlation.

 

 

 

Growing season precipitation, Idaho is normally dry, crops such as potatoes grow only with irrigation

System Design and Maintenance: The first step in optimizing the efficiency of any irrigation management program is to make sure the irrigation system is designed, maintained, and managed properly.  Increasing irrigation efficiency to derive the most crop yield from every increment of water available will generally produce greater economic return than any other change in management. Irrigation scheduling and irrigation uniformity are two key management factors affecting irrigation efficiency.  Irrigation scheduling involves determining the correct timing and amount of water necessary to maintain root zone moisture within the optimal range for crop growth.  Irrigation uniformity is related to how evenly water is distributed over the field area.  

 

Pivot Irrigation system showing inefficient uneven irrigation. Swing arms and end guns are not adjusted correctly. Note pivot is at one o'clock position. Light areas usually indicate excessive watering (lost yield) dark areas are under watered, (lost yield). Irrigation package needs to be adjusted, especially if water is in short supply.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Photo from FastMap

 

Problems with the nozzle package causes bulls eye rings. Dark: under watered, light:  over watered.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Photo from FastMap

 

Effects of more efficient irrigation from drip system.

             

Increase Available Water: An additional course of action is to evaluate possibilities for increasing the amount of available water per acre of potatoes produced.  Potential courses of action include purchasing additional water from surrounding water users, selecting other crops that are drought tolerant or reducing acreage of other crops and transferring the water to the potato crop, and reducing or eliminating potato acreage.

Stress, Yield, Quality:   Research has shown that potato tuber yield and quality will be impacted by even short periods of water stress.  The extent of the damage to tuber yield and quality will depend upon the severity, timing, and duration of water stress during the growing season.  

Over or under Irrigation increases the chance of quality reducing  physiological damage  and  disease as well as reducing yield.

 

 

Several studies have shown that water stress during the tuber set and early bulking growth stages causes the greatest reductions in tuber yield and quality relative to other growth stages.  Water deficits spread over the latter part of the growing season generally have less impact on tuber yield and quality than an equivalent reduction in crop water use over a shorter period of time.

Over irrigating or under irrigating impacts yield 

Nitrogen Fertilization. If deficit irrigation management is going to be implemented, the nitrogen management plan needs to be adjusted accordingly.  The degree of yield response to nitrogen fertilizer decreases markedly as crop water use is reduced by water stress.  Specific gravity is also greatly affected by water and nitrogen management.  Specific gravity generally decreases when water stress and high N application rates are combined. High nitrogen availability during late tuber bulking also often delays tuber maturity.  However, these effects are dependent on duration and amount of nitrogen and water availability, location, environment, variety, and other stresses on the crop.  Research in Idaho has shown that for every 15 to 20 percent reduction in water application from the optimum amount during the growing season, nitrogen requirements for maximum yield decline by 40 lb N per acre.  Applying large amounts of pre-plant nitrogen should also be avoided since it likely will delay tuber bulking and make the impact of late season water stress more pronounced.

 

Preplant N 13.0   Irr In 15.4   Irr In 16.8   Irr In 18.2   Irr In
0  lb N 42 cwt/a 282 cwt/a 282 cwt/a 303 cwt/a
40  lb N 277 cwt/a 315 cwt/a 318 cwt/a 324 cwt/a
80  lb N 273 cwt/a 315 cwt/a 328 cwt/a 334 cwt/a
120  lb N 259 cwt/a 305 cwt/a 318 cwt/a 338 cwt/a
160  lb N 253 cwt/a 301 cwt/a 307 cwt/a 324 cwt/a
 
When irrigation is reduced the optimal N rate is also reduced. Excess N only reduces yield

 

 FERTILITY MANAGEMENT

If irrigation deficits are anticipated, the nitrogen management program needs to be adjusted accordingly. The degree of yield response to nitrogen fertilizer decreases markedly as crop water use is reduced by water stress. High nitrogen availability during late tuber-bulking often delays tuber maturity in indeterminate varieties such as Russet Burbank. Research at Aberdeen has shown that for every 15 to 20% reduction in water application from the optimum amount during the growing season, the amount of nitrogen required for maximum yield is reduced by about 40 lb N/ac Applying large amounts of preplant nitrogen should also be avoided since it will likely delay tuber bulking and make the impact of late season water stress more pronounced.

 

 

If there is a projected water shortage that will be impacting yield, then the nitrogen recommendation should be reduced also. In particular the pre-season application (usually 30%) should be reduced.  Petiole sampling and in-season fine tuning for optimal results.  If the shortage fails to materialize in-season application should remedy the shortfall.

 

Pre-plant Nitrogen Reduction 

Seasonal Application
200 lb N 240 lb N 280 lb N 320 lb N
Drought Probability Water Shortage 30% Preplant N Recommendation 30% Preplant N Recommendation 30% Preplant N Recommendation 30% Preplant N Recommendation
0% 0 in 60 lb N 72 lb N 84 lb N 96 lb N 
5% 1 in 57 lb N 68 lb N 80 lb N 91 lb N
10% 2 in 54 lb N 65 lb N 76 lb N 86 lb N
15% 3 in 51 lb N 61 lb N 71 lb N 82 lb N
20% 4 in 48 lb N 58 lb N 67 lb N 77 lb N
25% 5 in 45 lb N 54 lb N 63 lb N 72 lb N
30% 6 in 42 lb N 50 lb N 59 lb N 67 lb N
35% 7 in 39 lb N 47 lb N 55 lb N 62 lb N
40% 8 in 36 lb N 43 lb N 50 lb N 58 lb N
45% 9 in 33 lb N 40 lb N 46 lb N 53 lb N
50% 10 in 30 lb N 36 lb N 42 lb N 48 lb N
 

Management Strategies for dealing with water shortages are relatively limited and are often controlled by decisions made at the irrigation or water district level.  However, producers can partially mitigate these effects by preparing for anticipated water shortages before the crop is planted.  In addition to deficit irrigation management, producers should also consider changing other cultural practices under their control, including extent of potato acreage, field choice, variety selection, and seed condition and spacing.

Field Choice. If possible, potatoes should be grown on fields that have the greatest potential for maintaining adequate soil moisture under deficit irrigation management.  Coarse-textured soils such as sands and sandy loams have low water-holding capacities and will lead to rapid development of water stress under deficit irrigation.  In comparison, soils with relatively high water-holding capacities, such as loams and silt loams, allow water stress to develop at a slower rate, reducing its impact on yield and quality. Fields with low variability will be easier to manage efficiently.

 

Variety.  

Variety Selection

Late-maturing varieties such as Russet Burbank are affected more by early irrigation cutoff than earlier-maturing varieties such as Russet Norkotah and Shepody. Therefore, earlier varieties are usually preferable in locations where surface water supplies may run out during the latter part of the season. In addition, some late-season varieties are less susceptible to drought than others. 

 

Variety choice can be an important tool in dealing with irrigation water deficits.  Potato varieties vary widely in maturity and in ability to withstand water stress.  One or both of these traits can help with avoidance of serious losses in short water situations.  Planting an early maturing variety can help a grower avoid crop damage resulting from a late-season loss of water supply.  Planting a drought resistant variety will minimize losses caused by any condition imposed by water shortage.

Varietal differences in drought resistance are illustrated by results of a recent study wherein potato varieties were exposed to five different water deficit scenarios based on Evapotranspiration (ET) replacement

Treatments included: 

  1. application of irrigation water to provide 100% ET replacement for the full season, (Full)

  2. providing 100% ET replacement until Aug 10 with no application thereafter (Cutoff)

  3. providing 75% of ET replacement for the full season (Reduced)

  4. providing 75% of ET replacement until Aug 10 with no application thereafter (Reduced Cutoff) 

  5. providing 100% of ET replacement until July 20 with a reduction to 75% of ET until Aug 10 and then decreasing to 50% ET replacement until vine kill (Step down)

 

Full ET irrigation always yields the maximum. But in reduced water years different varieties and methods will reduce losses.  

When water is limited different variety and irrigation choices may limit losses.

              Results of this study show that providing full irrigation through mid-bulking, followed by a slow reduction in irrigation amounts was the best scenario, in a water short situation.  Second, a late maturing, stress susceptible variety like Russet Burbank, is subject to large losses of marketable tubers under either moderate season-long stress, or sudden severe water stress caused by termination of irrigation. Third, an early maturing variety like Russet Norkotah can withstand late season loss of water with little or no loss of yield as long as there is sufficient water during tuber bulking.  Fourth, a variety like GemStar Russet, although affected by water deficits, can maintain high yields of marketable tubers, even under fairly severe stress. Results from this same study show that even varieties within a similar maturity class are affected differently by water stress.  Alturas, for example, is a late maturing variety like Russet Burbank and Ranger Russet, but is even more affected by late season loss of water supply.  This is likely due to a high water demand late-season, and its tendency for late tuber bulking. Below is a limited list of current varieties that may be used in deficit seasons.

 Early Maturing Varieties

Russet Norkotah

Shepody (on early delivery contract)

Ranger Russet (on early delivery contract)

Many red varieties including Red Norland, Red LaSoda, NorDonna, Mazama, Modoc

 

Drought Tolerant Varieties

Russet Norkotah

Ranger Russet

GemStar Russet

Gem Russet

CalWhite

Seed Condition. Physiological aging of potato seed often results in earlier plant emergence and tuber development.  If water shortages are anticipated late in the season, accelerating tuber development by planting seed that has been aged by warming during storage may be advantageous.  This may reduce the magnitude of yield reduction from early irrigation cutoff by completing more of the tuber bulking growth stage before water stress develops.   

 Summary. Potato production under deficit irrigation is not economically justifiable under normal conditions.  However, under regional drought conditions, it may sometimes be unavoidable.  Timing of water stress is important in order to maximize yield and quality under restricted water availability.  Spreading water deficits over the latter part of the season will result in the least reduction in tuber yield and quality.  Unfortunately, decisions made at the irrigation district level may limit the flexibility of deficit irrigation management.  If possible, irrigation deficits should be avoided during tuber initiation and mid-bulking.  Modification of irrigation, variety selection, fertility, and cultural management practices according to anticipated water availability can partially mitigate tuber yield and quality reductions.

 

Return to Top

 

 

Reduced Irrigation Methods

Potato Crops in Idaho require a 20 inches of irrigation in a season to match Evapo-Transpiration (ET). If the prediction is for a reduced water year cuts will have to be made.

  • Plant less
  • Plant crops that mature faster, or require less water

Or reduce the amount applied to your potato crop 

 

 

Yield Per Inch of Irrigation
When water is limited, the most yield per inch of available water would be planting GemStar and running 75% ET for the season.

 

2002 Aberdeen 

5 Irrigation methods 

6 varieties

2002 Aberdeen 

5 Irrigation methods 

6 varieties

 

 

2003 study

2003 study

  Results: There is a direct correlation between reduction in irrigation and reduction in yield. Each reduction of one inch of irrigation reduced yield by about 24 cwt/a.    

 .94 R2 correlation.

 

 

 

Return to Top

Return to Home HERE

Predictions

Field Trial Results for Reducing Water Use

Links for more information

Economics

 

 

 

POTATO RESPONSE TO DROUGHT

The extent tuber yield and quality are adversely affected by drought will depend upon the severity, timing, and duration of water stress during the growing season. It is critical to have an understanding of how water stress at each growth stage influences tuber yield and quality if a grower is to balance water supply with potential returns. Specific irrigation management guidelines for each growth stage are presented below.

Vegetative Growth - 

The vegetative growth stage begins at seed piece sprouting and extends to stolon formation. Water stress during the vegetative growth stage tends to acclimate (harden) the plant to water stress, potentially reducing the effect of water stress in later growth stages. Water stress during the vegetative growth stage reduces leaf area, vine and root expansion, plant height, and delays canopy development. Water deficits during vegetative growth have also been shown to decrease the number of tubers set per plant, which then results in fewer and larger tubers at harvest. Water stress limited only to the vegetative growth stage of Russet Burbank potatoes has been shown to decrease total yield but actually increase yield of U.S. No. 1 quality tubers. A general management guideline is to withhold irrigation until full emergence for silt loam soils, if winter precipitation has been sufficient to fill the soil profile to near field capacity. In drought years, however, irrigation may be needed before full emergence to limit water stress, particularly on coarse-textured soils. Under these conditions, it is usually best to apply irrigation before planting to minimize disease development. As a general guide, soil water depletion in the upper 12 inches of the root zone should be limited to 50% available soil water during vegetative growth. However, caution must be used to ensure that water stress is reduced or eliminated at the time of tuber initiation and early bulking. This will not normally be a problem with irrigation systems other than center pivots or linear-moves. However, center pivots or linear-move systems with flow rates less than 7 to 7.5 gpm/acre may never be able to catch up on irrigation throughout the remainder of the season.

Tuberization - 

Tuberization begins when stolon tips begin to swell and tubers begin to develop but are not appreciably enlarging (<1/2 inch diameter). Although additional tubers may continue to form on stolons during later stages of plant development, tubers that contribute the most to marketable yield are formed at this time. Water stress during tuber initiation can substantially reduce tuber yield and quality. In a 1987 field study at the Aberdeen Research and Extension Center, Russet Burbank potatoes exposed to moderate (10 days) to severe (14 days) periods of water deficits during different stages of tuber development had lower total and U.S. No. 1 yields when stress occurred during tuber initiation (Table 2). Tubers that are stressed during tuberization often are severely misshapen with pointed stem ends, multiple knobs, and other malformations.

Tuber Bulking - 

The tuber bulking growth stage extends from the time tubers are about one-half inch in diameter to canopy senescence. Under ideal conditions, this growth stage is characterized by a relatively constant rate of increase in tuber size and weight. Interruptions in tuber growth by water stress often result in misshapen tubers having knobs, growth cracks, and irregular shapes characterized as “bottlenecks,” “dumbbells,” and other irregular curved shapes. Thus, periods of water stress during tuber bulking often decreases U.S. No. 1 yields by increasing the percentage of U.S. No. 2 tubers. Sustained irrigation deficits during the tuber bulking will reduce tuber size and marketable yields.

The effects of water stress during tuber bulking were evaluated in an Aberdeen study in which the nine weeks immediately following tuberization were divided into three 3-week intervals designated as early (E), mid (M), and late (L) bulking. Constant water stress was imposed during 2 or 3 of these periods by irrigating at the rate of 80% or 60% of normal crop water use. The greatest reductions in total yield generally occurred when deficit irrigation was imposed during early-mid (EM), and mid-late (ML) bulking, regardless of water stress intensity. Spreading deficit irrigation evenly over the three periods or during the early- and late-bulking periods resulted in less total yield reductions. Effects of drought timing on U.S. No. 1 yield were similar to those for total yield. Water stress during the tuber bulking increased the percentage of undersized tubers with a corresponding decrease in 4 to 10 oz size tubers. Water stress during the early and mid bulking periods resulted in the lowest specific gravities and increased the percentages of dark ends.

In drought years, irrigation cutoffs during the month of August are highly probable in fields dependent on surface-water supplies. In a 1992 study at Aberdeen, water was cut off during the first or third week in August either abruptly or gradually over a 2-week period. The same amount of water was applied for both cutoff methods at a given cutoff date. The mid-August cutoff reduced total and U.S. No. 1 yields by about 13%, while cutting off water the first week in August reduced total yield by 30% and U.S. No. 1 yield by 50%. There was little benefit from gradual irrigation cutoff compared to abrupt irrigation cutoff. Late July and early August are peak tuber bulking periods and severe water stress during this period will substantially reduce tuber yield and grade, regardless of the manner it is imposed. Over the past 20 years, research at the Aberdeen Research and Extension Center has shown that total yield of Russet Burbank will generally be reduced 25 cwt/acre for every inch crop water use is reduced due to water stress during the tuber bulking growth stage.

Maturation - 

Maturation stage of growth begins with canopy senescence. Tuber growth rates gradually decline with loss of canopy, although significant amounts of carbohydrate are transported from the vines to the tubers during this growth stage. Exceptionally dry soil conditions late in the growing season not only reduce yield but can also shorten dormancy, reduce specific gravity, and increase reducing sugar content. Dry soil conditions can also dehydrate tubers, making them more susceptible to blackspot bruise. Consequently, care should be taken after irrigation is cut off to make sure the available soil water does not drop below 50% prior to vine kill. It is also important to get complete vine kill or removal since remaining live vines will continue to extract soil moisture.

Under dry soil conditions, the tuber moisture content or hydration level will steadily decrease resulting in increased susceptibility to blackspot bruise. Tubers can be partially rehydrated by irrigating prior to harvest. For tubers maturing in dry soils (<50% available soil moisture), irrigation should be applied about 7 to 10 days prior to harvest to adequately rehydrate tubers. Tubers maturing in soils with adequate available moisture (>60%) can usually be rehydrated by irrigating two to three days prior to harvest. Growers and irrigation districts should always hold back adequate water to properly condition the soil and rehydrate the tubers before harvest. This is particularly important on medium and heavy textured soils where soil conditioning is necessary to soften clods to minimize tuber damage during harvest. 

Return to Top